Blue Ocean Strategy – Kim and Mauborgne on Creating Uncontested Markets
Red Ocean
Compete for existing demand.
Industry boundaries are defined and accepted. Companies fight for share of a known market. Margins compress. The water turns red.
Blue Ocean
Create uncontested demand.
Industry boundaries are redrawn. Demand is created rather than fought over. The cost-differentiation tradeoff dissolves at the new boundary.
The right move is to
leave the fight.
W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne argued that companies trapped in red oceans optimize the wrong problem. The discipline they proposed redirects strategic effort from beating rivals to making them irrelevant.
A theory built on a long study.
Kim and Mauborgne, both at INSEAD, spent more than a decade studying strategic moves before publishing Blue Ocean Strategy in 2005. They examined 150 strategic moves spanning more than thirty industries from 1880 to 2000, looking for patterns in how firms created markets where none had existed (Kim and Mauborgne, Blue Ocean Strategy 4-12). The patterns held across eras and sectors. Cirque du Soleil, Yellow Tail wine, Southwest Airlines, all reordered the same set of variables and produced the same kind of result.
The central claim is that competition is the wrong primary problem for many firms. Beating a rival in an established category produces incremental share at compressed margins. Reordering the variables of the category produces a position no rival is configured to attack. The 2017 follow-up, Blue Ocean Shift, added the procedural detail, a five-step process for moving from a red-ocean starting point to a blue-ocean position with the existing team and capital base (Kim and Mauborgne, Blue Ocean Shift 32-44).
Cirque du Soleil is the canonical case. The circus industry was contracting in the 1980s, animal welfare concerns were rising, and acquisition costs for star performers were climbing. The strategic move was to remove the most expensive elements of the traditional circus, animals, multiple show rings, star performers, and add elements drawn from theatre, original music, refined acoustics, narrative structure. The result was a category, the artistic circus, that did not previously exist and that priced like theatre rather than like circus.
The Strategy Canvas, Cirque du Soleil against the traditional circus.
The horizontal axis lists the factors a category competes on. The vertical axis is the level of investment buyers receive on each factor. A strong blue-ocean move shows a value curve that diverges sharply from the industry standard, eliminating some factors entirely and creating new ones the category never offered.
Strategy Canvas method: Kim, W. Chan, and Renée Mauborgne. Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create Uncontested Market Space and Make the Competition Irrelevant. Harvard Business Review Press, 2005, pp. 24-29.
The Four Actions Framework.
Which factors taken for granted should be removed?
Industries inherit factors no buyer values but every competitor invests in. Removing them collapses cost without harming buyer utility.
Which factors should be reduced well below the standard?
Some factors have been overdesigned to outdo rivals. Reducing them frees resources for what buyers actually want more of.
Which factors should be raised well above the standard?
Identify the factors the industry has compromised on and that buyers care about deeply. These are the lift in the value curve.
Which factors should be created that the industry has never offered?
The new factors define the new market boundary. They are what makes the move difficult to copy and the position difficult to attack.
Three moves, three reorderings.
| Case | Eliminated / Reduced | Raised / Created | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cirque du Soleil | Animals, star performers, multiple rings. | Theatrical narrative, original music, refined venue. | New category at adult-theatre price points, contracting industry reversed. |
| Yellow Tail Wine | Vineyard prestige language, oak complexity, aging. | Easy drinkability, fun branding, clear varietal labelling. | Largest selling imported red in the U.S. within four years of launch in 2001. |
| Southwest Airlines | Hub-and-spoke routing, meal service, seat assignments. | Point-to-point speed, lowest fares, friendly service tone. | Sustained profitability across four decades while peers cycled through bankruptcy. |
Where the discipline pays, and where it falters.
The Blue Ocean argument pays off most clearly in mature industries where competitors converge on similar value curves and margins compress year over year. The framework gives a board a structured way to ask whether the firm is competing on the right set of factors at all, rather than asking how to compete harder on the existing set.
The framework has limits the operator should hold in mind. McGahan and others have argued that retrospective case analysis can overweight successes and underweight failed attempts at the same kind of move (McGahan 162-168). Survivorship bias is a real problem in the canonical case set. The discipline still has merit, but a board adopting it should treat it as one of several lenses, paired with a clear-eyed view of execution capacity and capital base. Most blue-ocean candidates fail not because the analysis was wrong but because the firm could not, or would not, fund the new value curve at the level required.
Five questions that put the framework to work in the next strategy cycle.
- What are the five to seven factors our category competes on, and how does our value curve compare to the industry standard on each?
- Of those factors, which two could we eliminate or sharply reduce without losing buyers we care about keeping?
- Which factors do buyers care about that the industry has historically underdelivered, and what would it cost to lift our position on each?
- What new factor, currently absent from the category, would buyers respond to if we introduced it, and is our team configured to build it?
- If we attempted this move, what is the realistic capital and time horizon, and does our governance permit a multi-year curve repositioning?
Sources
- Kim, W. Chan, and Renée Mauborgne. Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create Uncontested Market Space and Make the Competition Irrelevant. Harvard Business Review Press, 2005.
- Kim, W. Chan, and Renée Mauborgne. Blue Ocean Shift: Beyond Competing. Hachette, 2017.
- Kim, W. Chan, and Renée Mauborgne. “Value Innovation: The Strategic Logic of High Growth.” Harvard Business Review, vol. 75, no. 1, January-February 1997, pp. 102-112.
- McGahan, Anita M. “How Industries Change.” Harvard Business Review, vol. 82, no. 10, October 2004, pp. 86-94.
- Burke, Andrew, André van Stel, and Roy Thurik. “Blue Ocean vs. Five Forces.” Harvard Business Review, vol. 88, no. 5, May 2010, pp. 28-29.
Citations follow a hybrid format: MLA-style author and title, Chicago-style date convention, with parenthetical author references inside the body of the post.